I’ve signed a contract with Zondervan Reflective for a book titled As Human As Possible: A Christian Case for AI Minimalism. It’s slated for publication in November 2027.
Description
Rapid advances in artificial intelligence technologies call into question the very survival of human persons, at least in our current form. Tech boosters greet this possibility with great enthusiasm: we are on the cusp of a transhumanist utopia, and humans finally have the technologies we need to transcend our limitations—including our mortality—and grasp whatever we desire. Others, of course, respond to the marvels of AI with existential dread. Given these stakes, my approach to AI in this book may seem quixotic. Nevertheless, I’m going to argue that our ability to respond wisely to today’s AI technologies—and to whatever successors come in the future—depends on getting the human story right.
Learning the narrative script that God has given to guide our creaturely life is the only approach that’s adequate to the challenges posed by powerful and complex new technologies. And this is the approach Wendell Berry recommends when he states, “It is easy for me to imagine that the next great division of the world will be between people who wish to live as creatures and people who wish to live as machines.” Berry wrote these words in his 2001 book Life is a Miracle, and they’ve become a touchstone in recent discussions about digital technologies and AI in particular.
I recognize that it may seem odd to root a book responding to AI in the words and ideas of a man whose most (in)famous essay is titled “Why I am Not Going to Buy a Computer.” Yet Berry has thought deeply about how the technologies we use shape our lives and communities, often in unintended ways, and he’s done so from a set of agrarian commitments rooted in the rhythms of natural, creaturely life. This perspective enables him to focus on the anthropological implications of technologies that promise to replace human work—as the title of his 1990 book indicates, the fundamental question we need to address is What Are People For? Given the ways that AI promises to automate intellectual work, Berry’s lifelong “struggle to find or recover the language necessary to speak, in the same breath, of work and love” may help us more clearly articulate what it means that we are made in the image of a God who is love and how this vocation to bear the divine image should discipline the technologies we use to accomplish our work.